Founders Grab The Nearest Advice, Which May Not Be The Best Advice

November 16, 2026

By Chris Heivly, Managing Director at Build The Fort and Startup Community EIR @ Techstars

Founders under pressure grab the closest advice they can find, and it’s rarely the best advice. One question can tell you who has actually been there and who’s just guessing.

Boys helping someone in the pool

Desperate founders are a lot like someone in the deep end who just realized they can't touch the bottom. They'll grab whatever is closest, whether that's the lifeguard or a guy holding a pool noodle and a strong opinion about crypto. And founders are in that pool pretty much all the time. Cash is tight, a key hire just quit, a customer went quiet, and the board meeting is Thursday. Desperation isn't an occasional visitor. It's a roommate with an addiction problem.

So when someone offers help, the founder says yes. Of course they do. The problem is that the first hand extended is rarely the best one. It's just the fastest one. Proximity beats qualification every time, and I've watched it play out in conversation after conversation. A founder trying to raise a first round takes advice from a well-meaning friend who has never raised a dime but has read a lot of blog posts. Or from someone who raised once in 2009, in a completely different market, and now treats that experience like scripture. The advice is confident, free, and immediately available, and none of those things have anything to do with being right.

So how do you figure out who to listen to? 

You ask one question: "Have you ever been confronted with this challenge before, and what was your process and result?"

Notice there are three parts in there. Have you faced it, what did you do, and what happened? It's not "what do you think," because opinions are free and everyone has a few dozen. Process and result are where experience lives. Someone who has actually done the thing can tell you what they tried, what blew up, and what they'd change. Someone who hasn't will start sentences with "you should probably" or tell you a story about a friend of a friend who totally pulled it off. Pay attention to which one you're hearing.

This isn't a rude question, either. Good advisors love it, because they have a story ready and they're glad to tell it. The people who squirm are usually the ones who were about to wing it.

Here's where this matters for those of us who build communities. When a founder shows up with a problem, our job usually isn't to answer it. Our job is to ask that question of ourselves, honestly, and if the answer is no, to be the matchmaker. "I haven't done that, but I know someone who has, and I'll make the introduction today." That's a better outcome than a mediocre answer delivered with great confidence. A healthy startup community isn't one where everyone has advice. It's one where the right advice finds the right founder at the right moment, because somebody cared enough to route it.

Founders will keep grabbing the first hand. That's human nature, and it's not going away. But we can make sure the hand they grab belongs to someone who's actually been in the water.